Conditions of Use

Conditions of Use

All comments regarding the life and work of Lawrence Durrell are welcome. Say whatever you like, however you like. Comments are not censored, but they reflect the views of the commentator and do not necessarily represent the opinions of the administrator nor anyone else on this blog. All comments are copyrighted and belong to the blog. Fair use of the blog's material requires proper attribution both to the blog and to the commentator.

Friday, December 27, 2013

Prospero's Cell: Fake, Masterpiece, or Both?

Kudos to Ken Gammage for his comment of 26 December 2013.  He defines well the problem re Prospero's Cell:  A Guide to the Landscape and Manners of the Island of Corcyra (1945; 1962), which was Durrell's first and some consider his best work of travel literature.  But just what is it? — and who is the person or better, the persona, who creates this blend of non-fiction and fiction?  Of course, writers do something of this sort all the time — they invent and expand on reality to tell a good story.  Nothing wrong with a little bit of exaggeration, if done in moderation and for a good cause.  Patrick Leigh Fermor (a friend of LD's) writes his travel books in this vein.  So Durrell is certainly in this tradition.  He goes far beyond the usual limits, however, and I would argue that in so doing Durrell is fundamentally dishonest about his work and himself.  As David Green says in an earlier comment, Durrell's self is "edited" by his own hand — highly edited, I would add.  We'll have much to say about this topic.  For now, I'll limit myself to the contention that Durrell was a literary genius, but he was also a liar, a plagiarist, and a trickster.  He was essentially an illusionist, who deliberately deceived his readers and probably deluded himself in ways that are highly questionable.  Had these traits been known near the beginning of his career (he was 33 in 1945), he may well have been dropped by his prestigious publisher, Faber and Faber of London.  Feel free to disagree with any of my assertions.  —  BR

4 comments:

  1. Well that’s provocative! But I’m afraid you may have overplayed your hand. Remember, because of the new blog format, we are potentially open to (an infinitesimal fraction of) the internet-browsing world. So if you want to bring new readers over to your way of thinking (which I suggest is outside the mainstream,) the best path for that might be to start in the middle where most people are, and then gradually move them to your viewpoint by reasoned arguments. Yes, you can suggest that he might have plagiarized – or cited more transparently. However – liar and trickster? You’d better be a liar and a trickster to write the huge variety of great stuff Durrell did! He’s like the Kallikanzaros – a little supernatural Greek Leprechaun with a huge erection. Responding to your last line: if F&F or Dutton or whatever publishing house felt it needed to jettison all their soon-to-be bestselling authors because of the general category of *personal peccadillos* – well, I believe that would very quickly prove bad for business!

    Cheers! - Ken

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ken, yes, strong words. You have the better rhetorical approach, but I believe in stating my position openly and from the start. Many great writers were questionable human beings — Ezra Pound and T. S. Eliot, for example, both of whom were ardent anti-Semites. Eliot, it will be recalled, was Durrell's editor and mentor at Faber & Faber. Re plagiarism, Durrell took Eliot's famous statement — "Immature poets imitate; mature poets steal" ["Philip Massinger" in Essays on Elizabethan Drama, 1932] — too much to heart and too literarily. The story about Durrell and Faber is not my invention. I heard it from an anonymous source. He showed the evidence to a retired editor at Faber, and that person said the publisher would probably have dropped Durrell, had the facts been known at the time. — BR

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ken...

    The White Dice house nestled on the rocks of Kalami Bay is certainly the appropriate venue to try to get to the bottom of this question.

    I propose the AALDS books the White House for a three day workshop and exploration of Kalami Bay, Corfu township and the labyrinthic mind of Lawrence Durrell.

    Many unanswered questions will surely be resolved in this enchanting venue which throbs with islomane memories and footstep effluvia of Lawrence Durrell. Who knows we could employ some Gnostic incantations and Count D may make an appearance!

    Suggested dates anyone? Naturally invitations would be strictly limited.

    PS. I would be happy to revisit and share memories with the group of my infamous encounters with members of the IDLRs. Yes Bruce I will wear the red and green shoes for you!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dr. D., next year in Kalami Bay! By all means. What better place to hold the inaugural AALDS meeting. And don't forget to bring along your blue suede shoes! — BR

    ReplyDelete